Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content
How can we help you?
Planning

Appeal Inquiry: Land At (Os 5993 6704), Terrills Farm, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells

In this section you will find the following information:
In this section
Appeal Inquiry: Land At (Os 5993 6704), Terrills Farm, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells

Appeal Site: Land At (Os 5993 6704), Terrills Farm, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells

Planning Inspectorate Reference: APP/J1860/W/24/3353961

A public inquiry is taking place in relation to a planning appeal for Outline planning permission (all matters reserved, except access) for the provision of up to 125 residential dwellings and associated works. This is an appeal against the Refusal decision of the application.

About the public inquiry

The Inspector closed the Inquiry yesterday afternoon (Wed 26th February 2025), and therefore the Inquiry will not require to sit on the 4th March 2025.  We now await the Inspector's Decision in the coming months.

If you have any questions please contact the Appeals Officer by either email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or telephone 01684 862180.

Case Management Conference

On 12 December 2024 the Planning Inspector appointed to hear this appeal on behalf of the Secretary of State held a case management conference with the representatives for the Council and the Appellant which took place virtually. No discussion took place on merits of the respective parties’ cases and no evidence was heard or submitted. The purpose of the conference was to set out a clear indication of the ongoing management of the appeals and the presentation of the evidence so that the forthcoming inquiry is conducted in the most efficient and effective manner.

pdf Case Management Conference summary note (112 KB)

Indicative Inquiry Programme

The first day (Tuesday 25 February) will be held at the Abbey Hotel, Abbey Road, Great Malvern, WR14 3ET. The second day (Wednesday 26 February) will be held at the Council House, Avenue Road, Great Malvern, WR14 3AF. Although originally scheduled to last until Friday 28 February, the council’s updated position on its reasons for refusal means a shorter programme than originally anticipated.  An additional day the following week (Tuesday 4 March) has been reserved for a virtual session, if required.

Following the case management conference The Planning Inspector has set out an Indicative Inquiry Programme (this may be subject to change).

pdf Read Indicative Inquiry Programme  (102 KB)

Evidence Submitted to the Planning Inspectorate

The Council and the Appellants have exchanged proofs of evidence that may be viewed in the Core Documents at Section CD11 - Proofs of Evidence.

Core Documents

Below is the Core Documents Library. This includes all relevant documents (Core Documents pre-fixed CD) for the inquiry. This is currently a work in progress and will continue to be developed, updated, and populated in the run-up to the inquiry and may also be updated whilst the inquiry is sitting.

Not all documents relating to the application appear in the Core Documents Library, only the ones the Appellants and Council think might be referred to at the inquiry.  If the document you are looking for is not here then you will find it on the planning application search page(opens in a new window) (inserting application reference 22/00289/OUT) that has further information about the application.

document List of Core Documents (68 KB)

Core Documents List – Land At (Os 5993 6704), Terrills Farm, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells - (APP/J1860/W/24/3353961)

 

CD1

Application Plans

CD1-01

pdf Location Plan (Drawing no. P19_043_022C).pdf (3.46 MB)

CD1-02

pdf Illustrative Landscape Layout (Drawing no. 101 D).pdf (2.60 MB)

CD1-03

pdf Illustrative Concept Masterplan (Drawing no.P19_043_021_V3).pdf (14.47 MB)

CD1-04

pdf Access Road Alignment (Drawing no. VN211981-D109).pdf (215 KB)

CD2

Application Documents and Reports 

CD2-01

pdf Application Form.pdf (301 KB)

CD2-02

pdf Design and Access Statement prepared by Carter Jonas dated February 2022.pdf (9.06 MB)

CD2-03

pdf Planning Statement prepared by WSP dated February 2022.pdf (1.70 MB)

CD2-04

pdf Landscape Design Statement undertaken by TPM Landscape Ltd dated January 2022.pdf (4.51 MB)

CD2-05

pdf Landscape and Visual Impact Appraisal prepared by TPM Landscape Ltd dated July 2021.pdf (9.71 MB)

CD2-06

pdf Agricultural Land Classification report undertaken by Soil Environment Services Ltd dated September 2021.pdf (800 KB)

CD2-07

pdf Air Quality Baseline Report undertaken by Ensafe Consultants dated January 2022.pdf (1.87 MB)

CD2-08

pdf Arboricultural Impact Assessment Report prepared by WSP dated January 2022.pdf (2.33 MB)

CD2-09

pdf Biodiversity Net Gain Calculations prepared by Atmos Consulting dated February 2022.pdf (219 KB)

CD2-10

pdf Archaeological Desk Based Assessment undertaken by Archaeological Research Services dated November 2021.pdf (6.27 MB)

CD2-11

pdf Desktop Health Impact Assessment undertaken by Hodkinson dated February 2022.pdf (2.48 MB)

CD2-12

pdf Energy and Sustainability Statement undertaken by Hodkinson dated February 2022.pdf (1 MB)

CD2-13

pdf Flood Risk Assessment undertaken by Martin Andrews Consulting Limited dated January 2022.pdf (6.49 MB)

CD2-14

pdf Foul Water and Utilities Assessment undertaken by Martin Andrews Consulting Limited dated February 2022.pdf (6.75 MB)

CD2-15

pdf Preliminary Ecological Appraisal prepared by Atmos Consulting dated January 2022.pdf (2.46 MB)

CD2-16

pdf Transport Assessment prepared by Vectos dated January 2022.pdf (3.57 MB)

CD2-17

pdf Interim Travel Plan prepared by Vectos dated January 2022.pdf (1.42 MB)

CD2-18

pdf Foul Water and Utilities Assessment Revision B undertaken by Martin Andrews Consulting Limited dated June 2022 (received by LPA 15.06.2022).pdf (8.80 MB)

CD2-19

pdf Geophysical Survey undertaken by Archaeological Research Services Ltd dated March 2022 (received by LPA on 12.04.2022).pdf (3.81 MB)

CD2-20

pdf Air Quality Assessment undertaken by Ensafe Consultants dated 31.05.2022 (received by LPA on 08.06.2022).pdf (3.62 MB)

CD2-21

pdf Diffusion Tube Monitoring Survey undertaken by Ensafe Consultants dated 06.06.2022 (received by LPA on 08.06.2022).pdf (1.25 MB)

CD2-22

pdf Highway Consultant Response dated 16.04.2024.pdf (213 KB)

CD2-23

pdf EFM response regarding Education Contributions dated 11 July 2022.pdf (135 KB)

CD2-24

pdf WSP response to consultation comments dated 06.06.2022.pdf (99 KB)

CD2-25

pdf 5YHLS Addendum undertaken by WSP dated 22.09.2023.pdf (249 KB)

CD2-26

pdf Transport Assessment Addendum undertaken by SLR dated 05.01.2024 (received by LPA on 18.01.2024).pdf (11.95 MB)

CD2-27

pdf Highway Consultant (SLR) response to WCC Highways dated August 2022 (received by LPA on 14.10.2022)..pdf (3.71 MB)

CD2-28

pdf Education Assessment Email Correspondence.pdf (393 KB)

CD2-29

pdf Education Assessment.pdf (105 KB)

CD3

Statutory Consultee Responses

CD3-01

pdf Housing Team - MHDC response dated 14.04.2022.pdf (143 KB)

CD3-02

pdf Heritage-Archaeology WDC response dated 16.052022.pdf (55 KB)

CD3-03

pdf MHDC Community Services response dated 01.06.2022.pdf (240 KB)

CD3-04

pdf Worcestershire Regulatory Services - Contaminated Land.pdf (111 KB)

CD3-05

pdf MHDC Tree and Landscape Officer Report dated 12.09.2022.pdf (81 KB)

CD3-06

pdf Engineers - S.W. Land Drainage Partnership.pdf (76 KB)

CD3-07

pdf WCC Lead Local Flood Authority.pdf (72 KB)

CD3-08

pdf Tenbury Town Council.pdf (72 KB)

CD3-09

pdf Design out Crime Officer - West Mercia Police.pdf (72 KB)

CD3-10

pdf Hereford and Worcester Clinical Commissioning Group.pdf (216 KB)

CD3-11

pdf Worcestershire Children's Services Education Assessment.pdf (167 KB)

CD3-12

pdf Worcestershire Wildlife Trust.pdf (78 KB)

CD3-13

pdf Severn Trent Response.pdf (123 KB)

CD3-14

pdf County Highway response WCC.pdf (926 KB)

CD3-15

pdf MHDC Planning Policy Officer.pdf (13 KB)

CD3-16

pdf Worcestershire Wildlife Trust response to revised detail.pdf (59 KB)

CD3-17

pdf Worcestershire Regulatory Services Response.pdf (123 KB)

CD3-18

pdf REDACTED WCC Education response emailed agent 30.6.pdf (753 KB)

CD3-19

pdf REDACTED - County Highways Response - further info required.pdf (969 KB)

CD3-20

pdf MHDC Archaeology and Planning Advisor.pdf (74 KB)

CD3-21

pdf Tenbury Town Council.pdf (76 KB)

CD3-22

pdf MHDC Ecology Response.pdf (191 KB)

CD3-23

pdf REDACTED MHDC Economic Development Response.pdf (68 KB)

CD3-24

pdf REDACTED WCC Highways Response - refusal.pdf (982 KB)

CD3-25

pdf REDACTED WCC Highways Response to SLR Letter 2024.pdf (852 KB)

CD4

Third Party Responses 

CD4-01

pdf A & C Jupe response 1.pdf (434 KB)

CD4-02

pdf Thomas Rumble.pdf (95 KB)

CD4-03

pdf A & C Jupe response 2.pdf (430 KB)

CD4-03.2

pdf A and C Jupe, Linley House, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-04.1

pdf Mr and Mrs Steven and Leanne Cooper and Joyce Burton.pdf (1.14 MB)

CD4-04.2

pdf Mr and Mrs Steven and Leanne Cooper and Joyce Burton.pdf (1.34 MB)

CD4-04.3

pdf Mr and Mrs Steven and Leanne Cooper and Joyce Burton, Highfield, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8RG.pdf (83 KB)

CD4-05

pdf CPRE Worcestershire.pdf (549 KB)

CD4-06

pdf Joe Watson, 30 The Oaklands, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8FB.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-07

pdf Diane Fletcher, 29 The Oaklands, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8FB.pdf (80 KB)

CD4-08

pdf Teddy-Valerie Anson, 27 The Oaklands, Tenbury Wells WR15 8FB.pdf (78 KB)

CD4-09

pdf Mary and Alan Pollard.pdf (3.09 MB)

CD4-10

pdf Helen Keating, Laxton House, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (75 KB)

CD4-11

pdf Joe Watson, 30 The Oaklands.pdf (138 KB)

CD4-11.2

pdf Joe Watson, 30 The Oaklands.pdf (138 KB)

CD4-12

pdf Tenbury Doctors Surgery.pdf (12 KB)

CD4-13

pdf Alan Adams, Oak View, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (78 KB)

CD4-14

pdf Derek James, 7 Oak Bridge Court, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DS.pdf (76 KB)

CD4-15

pdf REDACTED Teddy and Valerie Anson flooding concerns letter 9-4-22.pdf (164 KB)

CD4-16

pdf The Reverend Ian Williams, 23 The Oaklands, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8FB.pdf (81 KB)

CD4-17

pdf MHDC ref_M_22_00289_OUT - field surface water flooding - flooded side passage.pdf (1.28 MB)

CD4-18

pdf Lynne Thorn and Robert Hughes, Kenelms, 17 Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (76 KB)

CD4-19

pdf Mr and Mrs M Leddington, 2 Sylverlands, Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-20

pdf Mrs Bright, Red Oak, Terrells Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (77 KB)

CD4-21

pdf Hilary Rea, Edmonton, Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8BY.pdf (79 KB) pdf CD4-22 Dot Byrne, Newlands, Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8BY.pdf (82 KB)

CD4-22

pdf Dot Byrne, Newlands, Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8BY.pdf (82 KB)

CD4-23

pdf Simon Ham, St Michaels, Tenbury Wells.pdf (83 KB)

CD4-24

pdf Andrew Nash, 16 Wyrebrook Orchard, Newnham Bridge, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8JD.pdf (73 KB)

CD4-25

pdf Katie Shorney, 9 Greenhill Close, Tenbury Wells , WR15 8BG.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-26

pdf Julie Cosgrove, 5 Kyreside, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8BU.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-27

pdf Andrea Harrison, 49 Wheeler Orchard, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DQ.pdf (75 KB)

CD4-28

pdf Miss M Danks.pdf (466 KB)

CD4-29

pdf James Davies, Clearways, Oldwood, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8TB.pdf (72 KB)

CD4-30

pdf Gareth Compton, The Dell, Newnham Bridge, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8NY.pdf (72 KB)

CD4-31

pdf Tony Gould, Beechfield House, 1 Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (76 KB)

CD4-32

pdf Maureen Robinson, 1 Cross House, Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DE.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-33

pdf David Illidge, Park House, Berrington Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8EJ.pdf (82 KB)

CD4-34

pdf Joanna Green, 7 Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8EJ.pdf (74 KB)

CD4-35

pdf Duncan Hooker, Old Barn, Sutton Court, Sutton, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8RJ.pdf (73 KB)

CD4-36

pdf G and M Robinson, The Woodrow, Berrington Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8EN.pdf (76 KB)

CD4-37

pdf Mrs Janine King, The Meadows, Little Hereford.pdf (76 KB)

CD4-38

pdf Mr S Glover, 22 Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DB.pdf (75 KB)

CD4-39

pdf David Middler, 28 Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DB.pdf (77 KB)

CD4-40

pdf Sara Glover, 22 Bromyard Road, Tenbury Wells WR15 8DB.pdf (75 KB)

CD4-41

pdf Derek James, 7 Oak Bridge Court, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DS.pdf (77 KB)

CD4-42

pdf Andrea Harrison, 49 Wheeler Orchard, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DQ.pdf (79 KB)

CD4-43

pdf Ian Williams, 23 The Oaklands, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8FB.pdf (75 KB)

CD4-44

pdf REDACTED Joe Watson.pdf (4 KB)

CD4-45

pdf Mrs Fletcher, 29 The Oaklands.pdf (88 KB)

CD4-46

pdf Lynne Thorn and Robert Hughes, Kenelms, 17 Terrills Lane, Tenbury Wells, WR15 8DD.pdf (78 KB)

CD4-47

pdf Steve Tack, Sundun View, Salt Box Lane, Tenbury Wells.pdf (440 KB)

CD5

Documents issued by LPA

CD5-01

pdf Officer’s Delegated Report.pdf (350 KB)

CD5-02

pdf Decision Notice.pdf (47 KB)

CD6

Relevant Policies within Development Plan

CD6-01

pdf SWDP 1 Overarching Sustainable Development Principles.pdf (1.37 MB)

CD6-02

pdf SWDP 2 Development Strategy and Settlement Hierarchy.pdf (194 KB)

CD6-03

pdf SWDP 4 Moving Around South Worcestershire.pdf (323 KB)

CD6-04

pdf SWDP 7 Infrastructure.pdf (136 KB)

CD6-05

pdf SWDP 13 Effective Use of Land.pdf (15 KB)

CD6-06

pdf SWDP 15 Meeting Affordable Housing Needs.pdf (239 KB)

CD6-07

pdf SWDP 21 Design.pdf (115 KB)

CD6-08

pdf SWDP 39 Provision for Green Space and Outdoor Community Uses in New Development.pdf (135 KB)

CD6-09

pdf SWDP 57 Tenbury Wells.pdf (8 KB)

CD7 Relevant Supplementary Planning Documents

CD7-01

pdf South Worcestershire Developer Contributions SPD (July 2018).pdf (947 KB)

CD7-02

pdf Worcestershire County Council Streetscapes Design Guide SPD (July 2022).pdf (2.91 MB)

CD7-03

pdf South Worcestershire Design Guide (March 2018).pdf (4.30 MB)

CD7-04

pdf Manual for Streets 2007.pdf (4.79 MB)

CD7-05

pdf Manual for Streets 2012.pdf (7.70 MB)

CD7-06

pdf Local Transport Note 1-20 Cycle Infrastructure Design 2020.pdf (14.29 MB)

CD8

Appeal Documents 

CD8-01

pdf Appellant's Statement of Case.pdf (932 KB)

CD8-02

pdf Appendices to Appellant's Statement of Case.pdf (4.89 MB)

CD8-03

pdf Statement of Common Ground.pdf (477 KB)

CD8-04

  pdf Appendices to Statement of Common Ground.pdf (14.58 MB)

CD8-05

pdf Council's Statement of Case.pdf (282 KB)

CD8-06

pdf Appendices to Council's Statement of Case.pdf (216 KB)

CD8-07

pdf Transport and Movement Statement of Common Ground.pdf (374 KB)

CD8-08

pdf Email setting out Highway Contributions requested.pdf (76 KB)

CD8-09

pdf Cover Letter- Highway contributions.pdf (80 KB)

CD8-10

pdf 1296-TN-01-A-Technical Note Flood Risk and Surface Water Drainage Statement.pdf (424 KB)

CD8-11

pdf Cover Letter- further response to Highway contributions.pdf (73 KB)

CD8-12

pdf CIL Compliance Statement Highways.pdf (127 KB)

CD8-13

pdf CIL Compliance Statement for Home to School.pdf (964 KB)

CD8-14

pdf Cover Letter- Outstanding Matters.pdf (108 KB)

CD8-15

document CIL compliance Statement LPA final.docx (34 KB)

CD8-16

pdf Signed Statement of Common Ground Post CMC Matters.pdf (831 KB)

CD8-17

pdf 5YHLS Addendum January 2025.pdf (252 KB)

CD9

Relevant Third Party Comments on Appeal

CD9-01

pdf Mr and Mrs Teddy and Valerie Anson.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-02

pdf Mr Alan Badlan.pdf (34 KB)

CD9-03.1

pdf Mr Christian Bright.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-03.2

pdf Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 1.pdf (176 KB)

CD9-03.3

pdf Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 2.pdf (210 KB)

CD9-03.4

pdf Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 3.pdf (200 KB)

CD9-03.5

pdf Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 4.pdf (177 KB)

CD9-03.6

pdf Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 5.pdf (169 KB)

CD9-03.7

pdf CD9-03.7 Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 6.pdf (169 KB)

CD9-03.8

pdf CD9-03.8 Mr C Bright - Landowner Statement Image 7.pdf (118 KB)

CD9-04

pdf Mrs Annie Bunting.pdf (34 KB)

CD9-05

pdf Mr P Cooney.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-06

pdf Mr S Davies - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-07

pdf Mr D Downwatrd - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-08

pdf Mrs D Fletcher - Interested Party.pdf (38 KB)

CD9-09

pdf Mr S Glover - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-10

pdf Ms J Grigg - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-11

pdf Mr S Ham - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-12

pdf Miss A Harrison - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-13

pdf Mrs K Hickin - Interested Party.pdf (37 KB)

CD9-14

pdf Mr G Higgins - Interested Party.pdf (34 KB)

CD9-15

pdf Miss E Holland - Interested Party.pdf (37 KB)

CD9-16

pdf Mr D James - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-17

pdf Miss K Jones - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-18.1

pdf Mr A Jupe - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-18.2

pdf Mr A Jupe Attachment.pdf (29 KB)

CD9-19

pdf Mrs S Lund - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-20

pdf Mr L Martin - Interested Party.pdf (33 KB)

CD9-21

pdf Mrs P Nicklin - Interested Party.pdf (34 KB)

CD9-22

pdf Mrs J Peel - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-23

pdf Mrs C Preston - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-24

pdf Miss L M Preston - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-25

pdf Mr J Sharp - Interested Party.pdf (34 KB)

CD9-26

pdf Mrs V Skinner - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-27

pdf Mrs D Taylor - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-28

pdf Ms L Thorne - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-29.1

pdf Mr J Watson - Interested Party.pdf (36 KB)

CD9-29.2

pdf Mr J Watson - Attachment.pdf (22 KB)

CD9-30

pdf Mrs L Wordingham - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-31

pdf Mrs L Penman - Interested Party.pdf (35 KB)

CD9-32

pdf Williams I - 1125567 - Interested Party.pdf (34 KB)

CD10

Relevant Appeal Decisions and Judgements

CD10-01

pdf Land at Pulley Lane, Newland Road and Primsland Way, Droitwich Spa Appeal Reference APPH1840A132199426.pdf (565 KB)

CD10-02

pdf Pickering’s Farm Site, Flag Lane, Penwortham, Lancashire PR1 9TP Appeal Reference APPF2360W223295498 and APPF2360W223295502.pdf (1.56 MB)

CD11

Proofs of Evidence

CD11-01

pdf Council's Proof of Evidence.pdf (139 KB)

CD11-02

pdf Appellant - Nigel Harris' Proof of Evidence.pdf (522 KB)

CD11-03

pdf Appellant - Appendix 1 of Nigel Harris' Proof of Evidence.pdf (34 KB)

CD11-04

pdf Appellant - Appendix 2 of Nigel Harris' Proof of Evidence.pdf (247 KB)

CD11-05

pdf Appellant - Summary of Nigel Harris' Proof of Evidence.pdf (291 KB)

CD11-06

pdf Appellant - Paul Whitaker's Proof of Evidence.pdf (11.54 MB)

CD11-07

pdf Appellant - Summary of Paul Whitaker's Proof of Evidence.pdf (258 KB)

ID

 Inquiry Documents

ID-01

default List of Council Representatives at Inquiry.odt (7 KB)

ID-02

default List of Appellant Team at Inquiry.odt (5 KB)

ID-03

default List of Interested Parties attending Inquiry.odt (5 KB)

ID-04

pdf Final Section 106 Agreement.pdf (1.13 MB)

ID-05

pdf John Barrett's Opening Statement (for Appellant).pdf (201 KB)

ID-06

document LPA Opening.docx (40 KB)

ID-07

pdf Cllr Lesley Davies Statement.pdf (627 KB)

ID-08

pdf Cover Letter- Confirmation of pre-commencement conditions (1).pdf (34 KB)

ID-09

pdf Draft List of Conditions 26 Feb 25.pdf (179 KB)

ID-10

document Mr Barrett's Closing Statement.docx (35 KB)